Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share
$775,000
3 Days On Site

5733 Carrollton Avenue
Indianapolis, IN 46220

For Sale|Single Family Residence|Active
3
Beds
2
Full Baths
1
Partial Bath
2,572
SqFt
$301
/SqFt
1931
Built
Subdivision:
Forest Hills
County:
Marion
Listing courtesy of McNulty Real Estate Services, 3175070688
Call Now: 317-578-3220
Is this the home for you? We can help make it yours.
317-578-3220
Upcoming Open Houses
Sun, Feb 9 5 PM – 7 PM UTC
5733 Carrollton Avenue5733 Carrollton Avenue5733 Carrollton Avenue5733 Carrollton Avenue
Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share

Charming updated English Tudor nestled in the sought-after Meridian-Kessler neighborhood of Forest Hills. This 3BR, 2.5BA home blends timeless charm with modern conveniences, making it the perfect retreat. The home immediately impresses with its striking limestone exterior, classic Tudor detailing, and incredible curb appeal. Inside, the beautifully updated kitchen boasts a breakfast bar, wet bar, stainless steel appliances, black marble and granite tile. The inviting dining room features elegant French doors leading out back, while the living room showcases a gorgeous gas fireplace with the original stone mantle and lovely Rookwood tile surround. Adjacent to the living room, the updated sunroom is filled with natural light and features new thermal pane windows/doors, limestone tile flooring, and a dry bar with ice machine…great for entertaining. Upstairs, there are 3 spacious BR's while, the remodeled BA offers spa-like experience with a shower, jacuzzi tub, custom cabinetry, and marbled countertops. Throughout the home, you'll find exquisite leaded glass windows, original light fixtures, and charming architectural details. The basement provides even more living space, including a cozy den with a fireplace and full BA…ideal for a guest, office, or entertainment area. Step outside to a spacious, fenced in backyard featuring a deck, tranquil water feature, cozy fireplace, and a charming gazebo…perfect for outdoor gatherings. Updates include: Total Kitchen Remodel: 2006 and later, Sewer/Water Line Replacement: 2008, Bathroom Remodel: 2009, New Asphalt Driveway: 2016, New Sunroom Remodel: 2016, New Landscaping/Patio/Deck/Walkways: 2016, Installed Supplemental Furnace/AC Unit: 2019, New Roof: 2019, Replaced Component Parts and Blower Motor to main furnace: 2024. Open House Sunday, February 9th 12pm-2pm.

Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share
Listing Snapshot
Price 
$775,000
Days On Site 
3 Days
Bedrooms 
3
Inside Area (SqFt) 
2,572 sqft
Total Baths 
3
Full Baths 
2
Partial Baths 
1
Lot Size 
0.19 Acres
Year Built 
1931
MLS® Number 
22020227
Status 
Active
Property Tax 
N/A
HOA/Condo/Coop Fees 
N/A
Sq Ft Source 
N/A
Friends & Family
Recent Activity
3 days agoListing first seen on site
3 days agoListing updated with changes from the MLS®
General Features
Acres 
0.19
Direction Faces 
West
Foundation 
Block
Garage 
Yes
Garage Spaces 
2
Parking 
DetachedAsphaltGarage Door Opener
Property Condition 
Updated/Remodeled
Property Sub Type 
Single Family Residence
SqFt Below 
474
SqFt Total 
3047
Stories 
Two
Style 
Tudor
Utilities 
Natural Gas AvailableCable Available
Interior Features
Appliances 
DishwasherDisposalMicrowaveGas OvenRefrigeratorWater Softener OwnedWine Cooler
Basement 
Partially FinishedStorage Space
Fireplace 
Yes
Fireplace Features 
DenBasementElectricGas LogLiving RoomMasonry
Fireplaces 
2
Flooring 
Hardwood
Heating 
Forced Air
Interior 
BookcasesBreakfast BarEntrance FoyerEat-in KitchenPantryWalk-In Closet(s)Wet Bar
Laundry Features 
In Basement
Window Features 
Bay Window(s)
Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share
Exterior Features
Construction Details 
Stone
Patio And Porch 
PatioPorch
Windows/Doors 
Bay Window(s)
Community Features
Horse Property 
None
MLS Area 
4903 – Marion – Washington
School District 
Indianapolis Public Schools
Township 
Washington
Schools
School District
Indianapolis Public Schools
Elementary School
Unknown
Middle School
Unknown
High School
Unknown
Listing courtesy of McNulty Real Estate Services, 3175070688



Listings courtesy of as distributed by MLS GRID. All information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties that a consumer may be interested in purchasing. All information is believed to be reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of 2025-02-08 11:14 PM UTC. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.

Copyright © 2025 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®. All rights reserved.

Neighborhood & Commute
Source: Walkscore
Community information and market data Powered by ATTOM Data Solutions. Copyright ©2019 ATTOM Data Solutions. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Save
Ask
Tour
Hide
Share